Why have we come to this place again? It seems like an endless cycle, and every time we’re caught here, I can’t stand it.
Every day at school, I’m reminded of how we were once inseparable—even a teacher commented on how she never saw one of us without the other. That was the only good thing about ninth grade, and it was a really great thing. Then, that selfish ex-friend of ours, who even still follows you around, tore our group apart, and we were cast to opposite ends of the alliances that were drawn in the aftermath tore us unwillingly apart.
Being in entirely different classes didn’t help either. Of course, until this year, our lockers were just two apart. Every day we at least saw each other, and said “Hi,” and cracked a few jokes with thin smiles and nervous laughter, still unwilling to really talk about what had happened, and how we felt about it. Neither did we confront the fact that we were drifting. But at least, we were in contact. Now your locker is around the corner.
Honestly, I think our group breaking us is the best thing that could have happened to you. The people we were hanging out with before really were unhealthy for us, and especially for you. Now I see you surrounded by friends, and I’m so happy for you, that now you’re enjoying school, or at least the people in it.
But then that’s part of the problem, isn’t it? You’re in an exclusive circle now that I’m not qualified to be in. I hardly see you anymore, and when I do, you’re with them. Namely, with her.
I hate her. It’s not because she’s annoying, or unfunny, or little Miss Know-it-all. It’s because she’s replaced me. I used to be your best friend, and now it’s her. We used to be inseparable, and now I never see you without seeing her as well. It’s like watching a movie of our life two years ago…only, she doesn’t deserve that position.
I was the one who stuck by you when all our fickle friends decided it was “Hate ________” Day. I was the one who did my best to comfort and counsel you when you cut yourself. I was the one who made you laugh at the administration instead of crying about them bullying you over your appearance. I was the one you went to for relief when your crazy girlfriend was being a drama queen. I was the one who was okay with you appeasing that awful ex-friend when she said, “Sit with me instead of Haley, or I won’t be your friend anymore.” You went through so many hardships, and I was right there by your side. Maybe I didn’t know as many “dirty details” as our other friends did, but I was always the one you came to for actual advice rather than simply attention.
Since then, you’ve become such a strong and wonderful person. I see you laugh and smile every day and bring joy to people’s lives. There’s so many things I admire about you. You’re talent is unbelievable. You’re always so cheering and ready to cheer others up. You’re kind to everyone, even if you can’t stand them. You’re upbeat and outgoing and friendly and funny. I could go on and on.
So why does she get to have that part of you? After being by your side and counseling you through your darkest days, she is basking in the happy lights of your transformation. And she is the same to you now as I was to you then, even though it seems I have done so much more for you. Sometimes I wonder if you’ve even noticed that I’ve fallen away and that she’s slipped into my place. I hate her for that. And truly, it’s not a deep, evil hatred. But it’s certainly more passionate than simply “disliking” her.
I love you. And I don’t just mean in the gushy romantic way. Probably in that way too, but I’m not experienced enough to be certain. But I do love you, more than it seems, more than you probably know. I want to share your happiness with you. I want to spend time with you every day, laughing together and talking for hours at a time. I want to listen to you play your music, and tell me your ideas and your dreams. I want to be best friends again, like we were back then, even more intimate than “boyfriend-girlfriend.” We’ve fallen so far from where we were, and as you run to your new friends, to her, there’s a hook in my heart that’s attached to yours, and it’s pulling and bleeding as I watch you disappear.
So now, every time I see you, every time you strike up one of those thin, awkward, “we weren’t as close as we used to be but hi,” conversations with me, all this pain comes gushing up. It hurts me when I see you now. I want to squirm and get away, even avoid you, because the pain is too great. And I do get away from you, which only drives the wedge between us even deeper. I know this, and it worsens the pain, and I begin to plan out my routes to avoid you in the halls, yet sometimes you catch me, and the cycle goes on and on.
I don’t know how to say all this to you. What is there to say? “Hang out with your other friends less because I want you to myself”? “Ditch that girl so I can have my spot back”? And on top of all this, you have a girlfriend outside of school. Is it wrong for us to hang out together, or go to dinner or see a movie, just the two of us, because you’re in a “committed relationship”? I hate high school dating.
I wrote a letter to you last year, during one of these cycles, saying how we’d drifted, and how I wanted to be friends again. You ran up and glomped me after you’d read it, and we had lunch together for the next several weeks. But I’d only revealed a fraction of my feelings to you, and it was like trying to throw a rope bridge across a still widening chasm. It seems now that there’s not a bridge big enough in all the world to hold us together.
So what should I do? Should I just suffer in silence, with this hook bleeding in my heart until graduation, when all the strings of high school are cut, and we go on our merry ways? Part of me wants this to be the case, because if it were, then I’d only have a little longer to hurt until you became naught more than a picture in a yearbook, that I would point out to my one-day children and say, “I used to be friends with him.” Rationally, I know this will most likely be the case. And yet there’s still that irrational, over-emotional, hopelessly romantic girl in my pained heart that wants you to be a permanent part of my life, forever.
Maybe one day I’ll be brave enough to send you this letter. But right now, I just don’t want to interrupt what has now become your wonderful life, with all your wonderful new friends, with some clingy ghost from your dark past. Part of me is scared that you really don’t want to be friends with me anymore, that you’re just being kind to me like you are to all those other people you’ve told me you can’t stand. And yet, when I look in your eyes, sometimes it seems you want to be best friends with me again too…